...it's like TV Tropes, but LINKED DATA!
Fox News Liberal
- 87 statements
- 14 feature instances
- 27 referencing feature instances
| Fox News Liberal | type |
FeatureClass | |
| Fox News Liberal | label |
Fox News Liberal | |
| Fox News Liberal | page |
FoxNewsLiberal | |
| Fox News Liberal | comment |
Otherwise known as a DINO (Democrat In Name Only), a 'Fox News Liberal' is an ideological Strawman character who is used to bring the illusion of political balance in a narrative or discourse that is otherwise overwhelmingly slanted in the other direction. Named after a critique of the Fox News Channel, a United States news organization with mostly right-wing programming, it has an opposite counterpart in the 'MSNBC Conservative' — named for a competing left-leaning US news organization — or RINO (Republican In Name Only). Like any straw man trope, the *INO character's job is to seem to be representing one point of view while actually promoting the opposite through the provision of a spectacularly bad advocate and/or role model. What makes a Fox News Liberal/MSNBC Conservative different from other straw men is that they are not playing a satirical or sarcastic role, and they aren't playing a fictional character. It's also very common for them to admit the solutions proposed by people with (what their superiors consider to be) the 'correct' political views are basically good and desirable, but quibble about the details or minutiae of their 'correct' policies.note e.g. "You're right, we 'should' kill everyone over sixty to solve the pensions crisis. ''However'', we should do this by issuing licences to unpaid volunteer-executioners so these 'Useless Mouths' can be eliminated at no cost to the taxpayer. 'My kind' are, after all, opposed to the use of the taxpayer's money to execute genocide." The presence of a 'Fox News Liberal' essentially gives a 'face' to the ideological enemies of the show and lets the show make ad-hominem attacks on them and by extension everyone who holds their views. For these reasons a 'Fox News Liberal' may well be ugly, rude, have poor public-speaking skills and/or a tendency to say the wrong thing (under pressure)... or maybe they're just really boring and speak in a monotone. The show itself sets the agenda for what is discussed - a Fox News Liberal will almost never be presented with a topic which "their kind" think is actually important, and the topic is often deliberately chosen to invoke all the poor argument techniques listed above. Other favorites include being more soft-spoken than the other hosts/guests, allowing themselves to be talked over, bullied, representing a skewed, poorly-articulated or crazily extreme perspective (even by the standard of their own ideology) for the host to handily dismantle, and never, ever getting the last word. In another formulation, the Fox News Liberal may be presented as the Only Sane Man with their particular political views. In appearing to be swayed by the 'superior' reasoning of their co-hosts, and agreeing with the position of the show, they make 'their' side look 'unreasonable'. Expect a heartfelt and theatrical sigh, followed by the words "If only the rest of them were as reasonable as this one is, the world would be a better place!" In particularly egregious cases of this version of the trope, the character's forsaking their (unreasonable) ideological beliefs and political allegiances (in favour of better/'the correct' ones) constitutes Character Development. The common thread is that their status as an official representative of their ideology is used to reinforce the ideology and/or viewpoints advanced by all the other co-hosts in general and the show as a whole. Being a token socialist or liberal on a panel show - wherein there are representatives of 'numerous' ideologies - doesn't count if the show itself doesn't have a political-ideological slant. Also, keep in mind that a Fox News Liberal might be sincere, having been given the job because they're singularly ineffective at presenting their viewpoint. See also Informed Attribute. Compare with No True Scotsman, for those people who disavow the Fox News Liberal as a "real" member of their political group. Examples |
|
| Fox News Liberal | fetched |
2023-07-20T05:29:55Z | |
| Fox News Liberal | parsed |
2023-07-20T05:29:55Z | |
| Fox News Liberal | processingComment |
Dropped link to BlondeRepublicanSexKitten: Not an Item - FEATURE | |
| Fox News Liberal | processingComment |
Dropped link to FlameWar: Not an Item - FEATURE | |
| Fox News Liberal | processingComment |
Dropped link to GranolaGirl: Not an Item - FEATURE | |
| Fox News Liberal | processingComment |
Dropped link to MisaimedFandom: Not an Item - FEATURE | |
| Fox News Liberal | processingComment |
Dropped link to PhilOchs: Not an Item - IGNORE | |
| Fox News Liberal | processingComment |
Dropped link to PoliceProcedural: Not an Item - CAT | |
| Fox News Liberal | processingComment |
Dropped link to WhatTheHellHero: Not an Item - FEATURE | |
| Fox News Liberal | processingComment |
Dropped link to WordOfGod: Not an Item - FEATURE | |
| Fox News Liberal | processingComment |
Dropped link to parodiedtrope: Not an Item - FEATURE | |
| Fox News Liberal | processingComment |
Dropped link to tropenamers: Not an Item - FEATURE | |
| Fox News Liberal | isPartOf |
DBTropes | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_18acb3a5 | type |
Fox News Liberal | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_18acb3a5 | comment |
In The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air, Will joins a group protesting the closure of a community centre in a majority-black neighbourhood, and gives an interview about it to a news anchor. When he watches the broadcast, it turns out that most of the interviews are with middle-aged white people who claim the centre is a source of crime and urban decay, and rather than Will, the protesters are represented by an Angry Black Man who yells at the camera, the implication being that the news channel is trying to skew the coverage and scare white viewers. | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_18acb3a5 | featureApplicability |
1.0 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_18acb3a5 | featureConfidence |
1.0 | |
| The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air | hasFeature |
Fox News Liberal / int_18acb3a5 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_1bd83c95 | type |
Fox News Liberal | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_1bd83c95 | comment |
Icon from Milestone Comics was created by a black liberal writer as a supposed black conservative. However, the in-story reason for him being a conservative is that he was born in the days of slavery when the Republicans were on the anti-slavery side (as well as being the more liberal of the two major U.S. parties, something that wouldn't change until the mid-1960s, when the Civil Rights Act and other similar laws were passed) and in modern times his sidekick started convincing him that conservatism is bad for the poor. This doesn't exactly fit the definition, but it approaches it. It's as if the writer wanted to put a conservative in, but as the trope description says, couldn't think of any way for a reasonable person to be one today. This is a complicated example, as "liberals" and "conservatives" of 150 years ago share very few traits with their counterparts of today except for the names, not to mention that he's a two-century-old alien ex-slave and probably wouldn't think like a modern human anyway. This brought a unique real-life case of Misaimed Fandom as several black neoconservatives, notably Clarence Thomas, would cite the comic as a favorite. This upset writer Dwayne McDuffie as he was not a fan of Thomas, often insulting him as "Scalia's lapdog" among other things. This gave McDuffie writer's block as he was concerned he was just giving quotes to the movement he disliked. |
|
| Fox News Liberal / int_1bd83c95 | featureApplicability |
1.0 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_1bd83c95 | featureConfidence |
1.0 | |
| Icon (Comic Book) | hasFeature |
Fox News Liberal / int_1bd83c95 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_247422c7 | type |
Fox News Liberal | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_247422c7 | comment |
In the Honor Harrington series, Catherine Montaigne is a devout Liberal and a good guy, while the Liberal Party as a whole are presented as bad and completely out of touch with reality. Coincidentally, while the Liberals are anti-military and favor socialist economics, Montaigne is pro-military, her economic views are indicated to line up with the Centrists (the party representing the author's views), and her only real support for the Liberal platform is in how she wants the Commons to be given more power (which the Centrists are also pretty cool with). In her first appearance in the mainline books, she confirms her husband's statement that she basically disagrees with the Liberals about everything except their strong opposition against cloning genetically engineered slaves. So the one thing the good liberal approves of the liberal platform is opposing something that doesn't exist in our world. | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_247422c7 | featureApplicability |
1.0 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_247422c7 | featureConfidence |
1.0 | |
| Honor Harrington | hasFeature |
Fox News Liberal / int_247422c7 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_3127e38 | type |
Fox News Liberal | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_3127e38 | comment |
The Newsroom The main character, Will McAvoy, a news anchor who identifies as a moderate Republican and had been a speechwriter for George H. W. Bush, repeatedly criticizes the current state of the Republican Party. He lists his conservative views, such as being for small government and strong defense, but also espouses a number of other views throughout the show that are pretty liberal, such as being anti-gun, pro-environment and pro-gay. He spends most of the show railing against Republican politicians (such as Sarah Palin, Rick Santorum, and the entire Tea Party) who he feels have hijacked the party. In-universe, News Night can't get a good conservative representative to support SB 1070, so they're forced to get a bunch of idiots and wack jobs who don't know the issues. McAvoy has to make their own arguments for them and feels that the show dropped the ball. |
|
| Fox News Liberal / int_3127e38 | featureApplicability |
1.0 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_3127e38 | featureConfidence |
1.0 | |
| The Newsroom | hasFeature |
Fox News Liberal / int_3127e38 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_59ef2cea | type |
Fox News Liberal | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_59ef2cea | comment |
Yellowstone: While the series has a somewhat inaccurate reputation as a conservative show, its treatment of environmental activism doesn't help. Summer Higgins is introduced as the ringleader of a large group of environmental protestors, yet in conversation, she's never able to mount even a paltry defense of her beliefs. Characterized as an insufferable Granola Girl, she spends her entire screen time getting trounced in conversation with regular cast members, learning to appreciate their opposing point of view, and getting easily manipulated. At no point is it even suggested that the characters should be learning anything from her. Stanley, the enviromental advisor in season five, who only exists to be fired by John for his opinions. His only crime was wanting to plant solar panels on a field of sage grass (which is useless on a pasture anyway), and not introducing himself to John sooner (which is John's responsibility, not his). |
|
| Fox News Liberal / int_59ef2cea | featureApplicability |
1.0 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_59ef2cea | featureConfidence |
1.0 | |
| Yellowstone | hasFeature |
Fox News Liberal / int_59ef2cea | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_60f02ddb | type |
Fox News Liberal | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_60f02ddb | comment |
Francine Smith in American Dad! is a Blonde Republican Sex Kitten who doesn't actually vote because politics confuse her, and on the rare occasions she does express political opinions they're often opposite her staunchly right-wing husband Stan. | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_60f02ddb | featureApplicability |
1.0 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_60f02ddb | featureConfidence |
1.0 | |
| American Dad! | hasFeature |
Fox News Liberal / int_60f02ddb | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_69d34e11 | type |
Fox News Liberal | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_69d34e11 | comment |
Trigger Warning, an anti-progressive screed masquerading as a "Die Hard on a campus" airport thriller, features exactly one sympathetic progressive character: Pierce Connors. (This is particularly noteworthy because several of his peers are set up to look as if they might do the same, but all betray the hero to save their own skins.) When he gets kidnapped with the other college snowflakes, Pierce realizes that he has an opportunity to fight back and reflects that his fellow progressives always wait for the government to try to solve everything rather than do anything themselves. He decides to actually do something this time and become a hero. In other words, his purpose in the novel is to be a progressive who highlights the hypocrisy of progressives by breaking with their ranks. | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_69d34e11 | featureApplicability |
1.0 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_69d34e11 | featureConfidence |
1.0 | |
| Trigger Warning | hasFeature |
Fox News Liberal / int_69d34e11 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_7950b30f | type |
Fox News Liberal | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_7950b30f | comment |
The Colbert Report: During the show's first season, Stephen Colbert's conservative alter-ego had a Sitcom Arch-Nemesis in the form of Russ Lieber, a liberal talking head played by David Cross, before the character was written out. | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_7950b30f | featureApplicability |
1.0 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_7950b30f | featureConfidence |
1.0 | |
| The Colbert Report | hasFeature |
Fox News Liberal / int_7950b30f | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_8c518367 | type |
Fox News Liberal | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_8c518367 | comment |
The Kentucky Fried Movie: Straw liberal Sheila Hamilton is one as shown by her crude rebuttal in Count Pointer Count. | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_8c518367 | featureApplicability |
1.0 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_8c518367 | featureConfidence |
1.0 | |
| The Kentucky Fried Movie | hasFeature |
Fox News Liberal / int_8c518367 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_9b2f1a7a | type |
Fox News Liberal | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_9b2f1a7a | comment |
Cessy from Empire is a housewife who at one point in the novel even provides a Biblical case for militarism in American foreign policy. At no point does she express any liberal views other than to remind the audience, every few pages, of how liberal she is. Needless to say, she is the only self-described liberal in the book who is not an evil, craven plotter out to destroy America. | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_9b2f1a7a | featureApplicability |
1.0 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_9b2f1a7a | featureConfidence |
1.0 | |
| Orson Scott Card's Empire | hasFeature |
Fox News Liberal / int_9b2f1a7a | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_9f8a2211 | type |
Fox News Liberal | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_9f8a2211 | comment |
While Marvel's Civil War was meant to be both topical and balanced, the need to make it topical had too many Pro-Registration characters do morally questionable things. | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_9f8a2211 | featureApplicability |
1.0 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_9f8a2211 | featureConfidence |
1.0 | |
| Civil War / Comicbook | hasFeature |
Fox News Liberal / int_9f8a2211 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_a32b6a64 | type |
Fox News Liberal | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_a32b6a64 | comment |
The West Wing, like most Aaron Sorkin shows, makes heavy use of Strawman tropes, including this one, despite attempts to resist using them. Ainsley Hayes, the Trope Namer for Blonde Republican Sex Kitten (with a touch of Southern Belle). Presented, at first, as a strong Republican that had previously been a member of the Federalist Society and could smack around expert liberal debaters, she quickly lost or strongly downplayed her initial displeasure about pork-barrel politics, gun control, and what she saw as unnecessary legislation. Her quick decision to leave gun control off the discussion table in response to a politician's attempted assassination is a particular moment, coming as it does from a Ronald Reagan Republican. Arnold Vinick, the Republican Presidential nominee in the final season, rejects enough Republican principles that it's almost impossible the real-life Republican Party would nominate him for President. He's pro-choice and not at all religious, although he's a big believer in economic conservatism, as in big tax cuts and reducing the size of government. Vinick's strong economic conservatism would not go far in the Democratic Party, and he's not extreme enough to be accepted by the Libertarian Party, so he's more of a Republican than anything else. Of course, he's from California, where Arnold Schwarzenegger, with similar views, was successful as a Republican politician, so his being a Republican Senator is believable note The peculiar position of California in this respect is discussed the moment Vinick is first introduced in Season Six, as President Bartlet intends to appoint him the US Ambassador to the UN. When Toby Ziegler expresses indignation that this post should go to a Republican, Josh Lyman retorts "Come on, he's not a real Republican, he's a California Republican!" . But as for his presidential nomination, it's telling that the nomination fight itself happens completely off-camera. Word Of God says Vinick was based on John McCain, who at the time of the show held similar views, though McCain was strongly pro-life. And McCain did win the 2008 nomination of his party, but by the time of the 2008 election, he had shifted considerably to the right. In fact, pretty much any Republican character whom the audience is supposed to like and respect gradually becomes one of these if they're around long enough. One particular exception is Speaker of the House and Acting President Glenallen Walken, who proves to be a competent president and reasonably likable man of integrity despite also being clearly depicted as a conservative Republican and military hawk. However, he was only around for three episodes, it's possible this wasn't intentional, and in any case, he was played by John Goodman, which goes a long way. Meanwhile, everyone who appears on the show and is to the left of the main characters seems to adopt the characteristics that Fox News associates with liberals: they are, almost to a person, shrill, mean-spirited, short-sighted, and egocentric. This is especially notable in any episode dealing with free trade, where opponents of free trade always get portrayed as hypocrites, grandstanders, or idiots. There's also Seth Gillette, a liberal Senator who calls out Bartlet's triangulations and is treated as a nut despite frequently being right. Basically, the door swings both ways: if Aaron Sorkin disagrees with you, you're either a nut or a meanie, and it doesn't matter what side of the political spectrum you fall on. |
|
| Fox News Liberal / int_a32b6a64 | featureApplicability |
1.0 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_a32b6a64 | featureConfidence |
1.0 | |
| The West Wing | hasFeature |
Fox News Liberal / int_a32b6a64 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_a9570fac | type |
Fox News Liberal | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_a9570fac | comment |
Mrs. Bingham and the other "strong women" on the Confederation's side in Victoria. They appear to be intended to show that women in the Confederation aren't oppressed, and do have agency and power, which sort of works (to a point) — but they seemingly only ever use that agency to push an anti-feminist agenda. | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_a9570fac | featureApplicability |
1.0 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_a9570fac | featureConfidence |
1.0 | |
| Victoria | hasFeature |
Fox News Liberal / int_a9570fac | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_ad29dc16 | type |
Fox News Liberal | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_ad29dc16 | comment |
In-universe, one episode of All in the Family has Archie Bunker complain to a local TV station about a pro-gun-control editorial. After he confronts the station manager, he's offered airtime to present an opposing view, with the clear implication that the manager is cynically satisfying the letter of the then-extant Fairness Doctrine while making the pro-gun side of the argument look bad (which Archie proceeds to do by suggesting that airlines should "pass out pistols" to the passengers to deter skyjackings). | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_ad29dc16 | featureApplicability |
1.0 | |
| Fox News Liberal / int_ad29dc16 | featureConfidence |
1.0 | |
| All in the Family | hasFeature |
Fox News Liberal / int_ad29dc16 |
The following is a list of statements referring to the current page from other pages.
Copyright of DBTropes.org wrapper 2009-2013 DFKI Knowledge Management. Imprint. - Thanks to Bakken&Baeck for hosting. Contact.
Copyright of data TVTropes.org contributors under Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License.
Copyright of data TVTropes.org contributors under Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License.