Search/Recent Changes
DBTropes
...it's like TV Tropes, but LINKED DATA!

That Was Objectionable

 That Was Objectionable
type
FeatureClass
 That Was Objectionable
label
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable
page
ThatWasObjectionable
 That Was Objectionable
comment
When a lawyer goes: Your Honor, I Object! or Objection, Your Honor!, one would expect them to follow that up with a devastatingly accurate reason, which could either turn the tides of the court, or shut the other side down, hard. But when Unconventional Courtroom Tactics are involved, objections are usually followed by complete non-reasons like: "I object on the grounds that it sucks for me" or "I object for it being objectionable!"
Most would expect that such a nonsensical move would get the lawyer doing it a lot of flak, and have the objection overruled, and most of the time that is how it will go down. But one can take this up to eleven by having the objection somehow sustained.
Objections are used by lawyers in court when they feel the opposing lawyer has asked a witness an improper question that the court should not hear the answer to. In comedies, expect the phrase to be used by someone who isn't a lawyer at all, believing it to be something you say anytime you disagree with someone. Can be a case of I Always Wanted to Say That.
Intentionally excessive use of this (see Real Life below) can be a type of Chewbacca Defense. See also Disregard That Statement. For the other "I object", see Speak Now or Forever Hold Your Peace.

Examples
 That Was Objectionable
fetched
2024-02-26T22:17:16Z
 That Was Objectionable
parsed
2024-02-26T22:17:16Z
 That Was Objectionable
processingComment
Dropped link to ACivilAction: Not an Item - UNKNOWN
 That Was Objectionable
processingComment
Dropped link to AceAttorneyInvestigations: Not an Item - UNKNOWN
 That Was Objectionable
processingComment
Dropped link to ChewbaccaDefense: Not an Item - FEATURE
 That Was Objectionable
processingComment
Dropped link to EaglelandOsmosis: Not an Item - FEATURE
 That Was Objectionable
processingComment
Dropped link to InherittheWind: Not an Item - UNKNOWN
 That Was Objectionable
processingComment
Dropped link to IronicEchoCut: Not an Item - FEATURE
 That Was Objectionable
processingComment
Dropped link to MotorMouth: Not an Item - FEATURE
 That Was Objectionable
processingComment
Dropped link to OlderThanTelevision: Not an Item - CAT
 That Was Objectionable
processingComment
Dropped link to SubvertedTrope: Not an Item - CAT
 That Was Objectionable
processingComment
Dropped link to TemptingFate: Not an Item - FEATURE
 That Was Objectionable
processingComment
Dropped link to TheOtherWiki: Not an Item - UNKNOWN
 That Was Objectionable
processingComment
Dropped link to TropeNamer: Not an Item - UNKNOWN
 That Was Objectionable
processingComment
Dropped link to TruthInTelevision: Not an Item - CAT
 That Was Objectionable
processingComment
Dropped link to Yourchonny: Not an Item - IGNORE
 That Was Objectionable
processingComment
Dropped link to runninggag: Not an Item - FEATURE
 That Was Objectionable
processingUnknown
ACivilAction
 That Was Objectionable
processingUnknown
InherittheWind
 That Was Objectionable
processingUnknown
TropeNamer
 That Was Objectionable
processingUnknown
AceAttorneyInvestigations
 That Was Objectionable
processingUnknown
TheOtherWiki
 That Was Objectionable
isPartOf
DBTropes
 That Was Objectionable / int_102a22a7
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_102a22a7
comment
And then there was Ansem Retort.
 That Was Objectionable / int_102a22a7
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_102a22a7
featureConfidence
1.0
 Ansem Retort (Webcomic)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_102a22a7
 That Was Objectionable / int_1463a028
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_1463a028
comment
An accidental one in Law & Order: Special Victims Unit, Novak objects that the lawyer is leading the witness on cross-examination. This is allowable and expected. Parties aren't allowed to lead on direct examination (unless they specifically get permission to do so — this is what "permission to treat the witness as hostile" refers to), but it is permissible during cross-examination specifically because of the difference in dynamic; the direct examination is trying to get the witness to tell their story, and therefore the questions need to be open-ended to ensure that the story is coming from the witness and not the attorney, but the cross-examining attorney is trying to impeach the witness' story and may need to ask specific questions in order to do so.
Barba gets a variation when a lawyer asks Olivia if her time as an SVU detective has led her to think all men are rapists.
One early incident had Detective Munch testifying against a doctor who sexually assaulted a patient under the guise of treating her for hysteria. The defenses objections resulted in Munch, unprompted by the prosecutor, giving a history of hysteria and its treatments, culminating in explaining why the vibrator was invented; that got a simultaneous objection from the prosecution and the defense.note Presumably the objection is that it's beyond the scope of the questioning and/or that Munch's expertise hasn't been established to the standard required for court testimony — both of which would in fact be legally valid objections — but the judge sustains it without even requiring either party to state specific grounds.
 That Was Objectionable / int_1463a028
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_1463a028
featureConfidence
1.0
 Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_1463a028
 That Was Objectionable / int_1b51bb94
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_1b51bb94
comment
In the The Addams Family episode "The Addams Family in Court", where Gomez is participating in a trial with the family observing, the entire family drives the judge nuts, including Uncle Fester who says "I Object!" just so he can participate in the trial, despite the fact that he is in the audience and thus obviously not supposed to interfere.
 That Was Objectionable / int_1b51bb94
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_1b51bb94
featureConfidence
1.0
 The Addams Family
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_1b51bb94
 That Was Objectionable / int_20948a39
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_20948a39
comment
In Tales of Monkey Island, Guybrush has the option of doing this while on trial; it's one of many ways to anger the judge (necessary to solve a puzzle).
 That Was Objectionable / int_20948a39
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_20948a39
featureConfidence
1.0
 Tales of Monkey Island (Video Game)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_20948a39
 That Was Objectionable / int_2191a786
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_2191a786
comment
Fatal Instinct: Spoofed during Lana Ravine's trial.
 That Was Objectionable / int_2191a786
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_2191a786
featureConfidence
1.0
 Fatal Instinct
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_2191a786
 That Was Objectionable / int_22211d68
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_22211d68
comment
Bones
When Brennan's father was on trial for murder.
In the same episode, although she didn't actually object, Angela took the fifth to prevent herself from having to incriminate someone else. She was told that the Fifth Amendment only protected her from incriminating herself. She wound up taking the First, which protects freedom of assembly, including friendship, and is four better than the Fifth! The judge was not impressed.
Also:
 That Was Objectionable / int_22211d68
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_22211d68
featureConfidence
1.0
 Bones
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_22211d68
 That Was Objectionable / int_22e860f4
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_22e860f4
comment
Psych uses this one in “Cloudy With a Chance of Murder.�
 That Was Objectionable / int_22e860f4
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_22e860f4
featureConfidence
1.0
 Psych
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_22e860f4
 That Was Objectionable / int_261c8d3f
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_261c8d3f
comment
The Simpsons:
Another episode has Hutz get so fed up of hearing the words "objection" followed by "sustained" that he announces if he hears it one more time he'll scream. Sure enough...
 That Was Objectionable / int_261c8d3f
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_261c8d3f
featureConfidence
1.0
 The Simpsons
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_261c8d3f
 That Was Objectionable / int_27a2d64a
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_27a2d64a
comment
Parodied in Extras in the Orlando Bloom episode, which opens as usual with a scene from the movie-within-a-show that's being filmed, which appears to be a courtroom-drama-romantic-comedy-of-manners. Bloom, the prosecuting attorney: "It seems very odd that you would send your wife flowers and not include a card. Whenever I send my wife flowers, I always write a card." Up pops the defense attorney: "Objection! When did you ever send me flowers?" This escalates into an argument, which the judge resolves by declaring, "I order you two to kiss and make up!"
 That Was Objectionable / int_27a2d64a
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_27a2d64a
featureConfidence
1.0
 Extras
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_27a2d64a
 That Was Objectionable / int_2e3e7ac2
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_2e3e7ac2
comment
In an early Justice League episode, Green Lantern is being framed for the destruction of a planet and is being put on trial. When GL gets found guilty and the judge starts to sentence him, the Flash tries to interrupt with an "Objection!", which is denied.
 That Was Objectionable / int_2e3e7ac2
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_2e3e7ac2
featureConfidence
1.0
 Justice League
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_2e3e7ac2
 That Was Objectionable / int_2e621178
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_2e621178
comment
On The Good Wife, Alicia Florick is up against her former boss Stern. Stern is in the early stages of Alzheimer's Disease, something he's only told Alicia and she can't tell anyone else because he told her at a previous time when he was her client. She gets around this by repeatedly raising frivolous objections during one of Stern's cross-examinations, causing him to become confused and forget what he was going to ask next.
 That Was Objectionable / int_2e621178
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_2e621178
featureConfidence
1.0
 The Good Wife
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_2e621178
 That Was Objectionable / int_32e7b181
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_32e7b181
comment
On Unhappily Ever After, Ryan once rattled off three or four of these in a quick montage. The most memorable one was this: "I have contempt for this court!"
 That Was Objectionable / int_32e7b181
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_32e7b181
featureConfidence
1.0
 Unhappily Ever After
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_32e7b181
 That Was Objectionable / int_3558eaa2
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_3558eaa2
comment
Community: Played for Laughs during "Basic Lupine Urology," with the case of the murdered yam.
 That Was Objectionable / int_3558eaa2
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_3558eaa2
featureConfidence
1.0
 Community
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_3558eaa2
 That Was Objectionable / int_3ae518ad
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_3ae518ad
comment
In Idiocracy, Joe's lawyer tries to object to the judge's clear bias, forgets and objects that "he won't be able to pay ME after he gives back all the money he stole from the hospital!"
 That Was Objectionable / int_3ae518ad
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_3ae518ad
featureConfidence
1.0
 Idiocracy
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_3ae518ad
 That Was Objectionable / int_3b7e691d
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_3b7e691d
comment
Done by the Genie in Aladdin and the King of Thieves during Aladdin's trial.
 That Was Objectionable / int_3b7e691d
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_3b7e691d
featureConfidence
1.0
 Aladdin and the King of Thieves
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_3b7e691d
 That Was Objectionable / int_3c4ddc1e
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_3c4ddc1e
comment
Elly of For Better or for Worse goes to court to contest a traffic ticket. When the plaintiff's lawyer is explaining the situation, Elly (who is defending herself) hastily objects. The judge explains that she needs to stand up and say "Your Honor"; Elly even more passionately shoots to her feet and shrieks, "On my honor, I object!"
 That Was Objectionable / int_3c4ddc1e
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_3c4ddc1e
featureConfidence
1.0
 For Better or for Worse (Comic Strip)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_3c4ddc1e
 That Was Objectionable / int_3ccfa555
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_3ccfa555
comment
In Trials and Tribulations Godot objects, just before throwing a cup of coffee over Phoenix's face.
 That Was Objectionable / int_3ccfa555
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_3ccfa555
featureConfidence
1.0
 Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney – Trials and Tribulations (Visual Novel)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_3ccfa555
 That Was Objectionable / int_43dfe888
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_43dfe888
comment
In The Rats, The Bats, and the Ugly, there is an oddly phrased but technically valid objection during Chip's second court martial.
 That Was Objectionable / int_43dfe888
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_43dfe888
featureConfidence
1.0
 Rats, Bats and Vats
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_43dfe888
 That Was Objectionable / int_455e3038
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_455e3038
comment
After Hank accidentally saws off Dale's index finger (it gets reattached) in King of the Hill, Dale has a judge impose a restraining order. While Hank gives his account and his history with Dale:
 That Was Objectionable / int_455e3038
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_455e3038
featureConfidence
1.0
 King of the Hill
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_455e3038
 That Was Objectionable / int_47607004
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_47607004
comment
Played with on The Closer. The lawyer gives two perfectly reasonable objections, then follows it with a silly one for kicks.
 That Was Objectionable / int_47607004
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_47607004
featureConfidence
1.0
 The Closer
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_47607004
 That Was Objectionable / int_5307b01d
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_5307b01d
comment
Played up in one Penny Arcade strip.
 That Was Objectionable / int_5307b01d
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_5307b01d
featureConfidence
1.0
 Penny Arcade (Webcomic)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_5307b01d
 That Was Objectionable / int_546876cb
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_546876cb
comment
Sonic Boom:
 That Was Objectionable / int_546876cb
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_546876cb
featureConfidence
1.0
 Sonic Boom
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_546876cb
 That Was Objectionable / int_56b62db5
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_56b62db5
comment
In the spin-off crossover Professor Layton vs. Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney in the final case when the Storyteller lays out the whole convoluted plot, pressing the first statement has Phoenix say "HOLD IT!" followed by a bewildered yell, being unable to wrap his head around it.
One of the Special Episodes features Edgeworth solving a puzzle. His victory one-liner is a Call-Back to his trope-naming original quote.
 That Was Objectionable / int_56b62db5
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_56b62db5
featureConfidence
1.0
 Professor Layton vs. Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney (Video Game)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_56b62db5
 That Was Objectionable / int_5c1a9545
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_5c1a9545
comment
Subverted in an episode of The Practice, in which Bobby Donnell is so exhausted due to lack of sleep that he can barely stay awake in the courtroom. Opposing counsel says something ridiculous that the judge (and by this point, the audience) would reasonably expect Bobby to loudly object to. The judge looks at Bobby, who is dozing off, waits a beat, and just says "Sustained" anyway.
 That Was Objectionable / int_5c1a9545
featureApplicability
-0.3
 That Was Objectionable / int_5c1a9545
featureConfidence
1.0
 The Practice
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_5c1a9545
 That Was Objectionable / int_5c897f4a
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_5c897f4a
comment
Schlock Mercenary: During the court room portion of the HTRN Takedown arc, Captain Tagon is forced to defend himself in Petey's court, since Petey doesn't allow lawyers.
 That Was Objectionable / int_5c897f4a
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_5c897f4a
featureConfidence
1.0
 Schlock Mercenary (Webcomic)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_5c897f4a
 That Was Objectionable / int_5d354f8
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_5d354f8
comment
In the Red Dwarf episode "Justice", Kryten's defence of Rimmer on 1,169 counts of manslaughter is to present him (accurately) as a sad incompetent. Naturally, Rimmer can't bring himself to let this slide, and repeatedly objects to his own defence. After he's found innocent, he objects again.
 That Was Objectionable / int_5d354f8
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_5d354f8
featureConfidence
1.0
 Red Dwarf
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_5d354f8
 That Was Objectionable / int_5d7f0a07
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_5d7f0a07
comment
Turnabout Storm has Twilight objecting during the trial on the grounds of "This can't go on!". Of course, considering the target of and the circumstances behind the objection, it's anything but Played for Laughs.
 That Was Objectionable / int_5d7f0a07
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_5d7f0a07
featureConfidence
1.0
 Turnabout Storm (Web Animation)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_5d7f0a07
 That Was Objectionable / int_61750a5f
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_61750a5f
comment
In the Porridge episode "Rough Justice", Stephen Rawley (a judge convicted of corruption) finds his watch has gone missing, and Fletcher decides Harris stole it, and arranges a trial with himself prosecuting, Warren defending and Rawley (against his better judgement) on the bench. It starts well:
 That Was Objectionable / int_61750a5f
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_61750a5f
featureConfidence
1.0
 Porridge
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_61750a5f
 That Was Objectionable / int_70c7b114
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_70c7b114
comment
Gilligan's Island: In "Plant You Now, Dig You Later", during a mock-courtroom scene, the Skipper and Mr. Howell (acting as lawyers) object several times. In one case, Mr. Howell can't actually think of a reason for the objection. Then the following exchange occurs:
 That Was Objectionable / int_70c7b114
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_70c7b114
featureConfidence
1.0
 Gilligan's Island
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_70c7b114
 That Was Objectionable / int_72e68fc6
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_72e68fc6
comment
And case 5 of Spirit of Justice gives us this:
 That Was Objectionable / int_72e68fc6
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_72e68fc6
featureConfidence
1.0
 Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney – Spirit of Justice (Visual Novel)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_72e68fc6
 That Was Objectionable / int_75149ccd
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_75149ccd
comment
Subtle example in The Krytos Trap. The setting is a military trial, where Tycho Celchu has been charged with the murder of Corran Horn. Commander Ettyk, the prosecutor, is questioning a witness (Iella Wessiri) who had partnered with Horn in the past, and who had also participated in the retaking of Coruscant with Horn. The direct examination concluded more or less as follows:
 That Was Objectionable / int_75149ccd
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_75149ccd
featureConfidence
1.0
 X-Wing Series
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_75149ccd
 That Was Objectionable / int_7953de6a
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_7953de6a
comment
Newsies:
 That Was Objectionable / int_7953de6a
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_7953de6a
featureConfidence
1.0
 Newsies
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_7953de6a
 That Was Objectionable / int_7d20ef2c
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_7d20ef2c
comment
One Bloom County strip had legal assistant Opus damning the torpedoes and going for the gusto in court:
 That Was Objectionable / int_7d20ef2c
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_7d20ef2c
featureConfidence
1.0
 Bloom County (Comic Strip)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_7d20ef2c
 That Was Objectionable / int_7fc53da4
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_7fc53da4
comment
In one episode of The Magic School Bus when Ms. Frizzle takes the class on one of her field trips while on trial for stealing Keisha's cucumber, Arnold objects to "being the smallest defense attorney in history."
 That Was Objectionable / int_7fc53da4
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_7fc53da4
featureConfidence
1.0
 TheMagicSchoolBus
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_7fc53da4
 That Was Objectionable / int_8197ebd8
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_8197ebd8
comment
Two different cases in General Protection Fault.
Case 1, Fooker's trial in the Ubersoft crossover.
Case 2, Man vs. Mold. Upon being told that her plaintiff (Trent) had been convicted for attempted murder before:
 That Was Objectionable / int_8197ebd8
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_8197ebd8
featureConfidence
1.0
 General Protection Fault (Webcomic)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_8197ebd8
 That Was Objectionable / int_83d41855
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_83d41855
comment
In the non-canon Gargoyles episode "And Justice For All", Goliath's public defender Amy is trying to stall for time for Goliath to bring back decisive evidence proving his innocence to the judge. When she's about to pass judgment on him for having escaped from custody, Amy can only weakly object to the use of the word "escaped".
 That Was Objectionable / int_83d41855
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_83d41855
featureConfidence
1.0
 Gargoyles
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_83d41855
 That Was Objectionable / int_8516bd41
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_8516bd41
comment
Chicago:
 That Was Objectionable / int_8516bd41
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_8516bd41
featureConfidence
1.0
 Chicago (Theatre)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_8516bd41
 That Was Objectionable / int_858624ba
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_858624ba
comment
Will & Grace: Grace attempts to sue a client who refuses to pay her over disagreements with her interior design choices. She ends up representing herself in arbitration after the client (who's partner at a major law firm) hires Will and orders him to handle the case.
 That Was Objectionable / int_858624ba
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_858624ba
featureConfidence
1.0
 Will & Grace
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_858624ba
 That Was Objectionable / int_8d814070
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_8d814070
comment
Inverted on M*A*S*H, when Hawkeye allows a military lawyer to scrub up and observe them in the operating room.
 That Was Objectionable / int_8d814070
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_8d814070
featureConfidence
1.0
 M*A*S*H
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_8d814070
 That Was Objectionable / int_8dfbdff2
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_8dfbdff2
comment
Played with in one episode of Law & Order when a defense attorney tries to suppress an alleged search of her clients' home on the grounds that the police didn't have a warrant for said search...except when she serves this motion to the prosecution, they have no idea what she's talking about and didn't even know the evidence she's referring to existed. As far as the defense attorney is aware, her motion is valid, but the prosecution correctly points out that the court can't exclude evidence the prosecution isn't in possession of.
 That Was Objectionable / int_8dfbdff2
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_8dfbdff2
featureConfidence
1.0
 Law & Order
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_8dfbdff2
 That Was Objectionable / int_8f58ab76
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_8f58ab76
comment
Liar Liar has the most honest version:
 That Was Objectionable / int_8f58ab76
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_8f58ab76
featureConfidence
1.0
 Liar Liar
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_8f58ab76
 That Was Objectionable / int_91e45f5
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_91e45f5
comment
In Apollo Justice's first trial, when the prosecution states that the victim was the winner of the poker game:
 That Was Objectionable / int_91e45f5
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_91e45f5
featureConfidence
1.0
 Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney (Visual Novel)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_91e45f5
 That Was Objectionable / int_9284ad43
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_9284ad43
comment
In Dual Destinies, with Phoenix during the first case.
 That Was Objectionable / int_9284ad43
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_9284ad43
featureConfidence
1.0
 Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney – Dual Destinies (Visual Novel)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_9284ad43
 That Was Objectionable / int_99055407
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_99055407
comment
Family Matters has Steve Urkel accused of blowing up the science lab. Knowing he is innocent, Laura defends him in a trial held before the Absurdly Powerful Student Council. Carl is called upon by the prosecution to describe the many, many, many disasters Steve has caused at their house. On cross-examination, Laura establishes that Steve has always taken responsibility for his mistakes, and asks Carl why Steve isn't claiming this one.
 That Was Objectionable / int_99055407
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_99055407
featureConfidence
1.0
 Family Matters
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_99055407
 That Was Objectionable / int_9b412c87
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_9b412c87
comment
In Little Fuzzy, the objections start before the trial begins.
Gus Brannhard (Jack Holloway's lawyer) objects to Leonard Kellogg being tried first and Leslie Coombes (Kellogg's lawyer) has the same objection to Holloway being tried first. Chief Justice Pendarvis resolves both objections by ordering the two trials combined, and swearing in each defense lawyer as a special prosecutor against the other's client.
During the testimony of the first witness, Coombes objects to the witness referring to fuzzies as "people," and Brannhard immediately counter-objects to the witness being forced to not refer to fuzzies as people.
After Kellogg commits suicide in jail, Coombs objection to "the farce of trying a dead man" is shot down by citing People of the Colony of Baphomet versus Jamshar Singh, Deceased. It's a Running Gag that one could find a precedent in colonial law for almost anything.
 That Was Objectionable / int_9b412c87
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_9b412c87
featureConfidence
1.0
 Little Fuzzy
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_9b412c87
 That Was Objectionable / int_9c41abf2
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_9c41abf2
comment
Judgment at Nuremberg has a Played for Drama version of this trope, when the prosecutor brings up the Feldenstein Case, a notorious incident where a Jewish merchant was sentenced to death by a Third Reich Kangaroo Court that was presided over by one of the four judges on trial. The defending lawyer, Rolfe, tries objecting, but stumbles over his words while trying to find a reason and can only claim that it's too sensitive a topic to discuss, which naturally holds no water in a trial regarding crimes against humanity. Until this point Rolfe had been skilfully rebutting the prosecution's arguments, so the fact that he's trying to object despite knowing he has no good grounds to do so indicates just how royally screwed his client will be by discussion of the Feldensein Case.
 That Was Objectionable / int_9c41abf2
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_9c41abf2
featureConfidence
1.0
 Judgment at Nuremberg
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_9c41abf2
 That Was Objectionable / int_9dd8fa62
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_9dd8fa62
comment
LegalEagle has explained that such a tactic, that is objecting when you know will be overruled, is actually a valid tactic in court battles. For one, even if the objection is overruled it still goes on record that you objected, and if you don't it can hurt your attempt at an appeal because they are likely to question why you didn't object during the court case. Another is that is simply breaks up the flow of opposing counsel, which can prevent them from getting into a good tangent or speech and make them lose their train of thought. Of course, he is quick to point out that being too trigger-happy with objections is annoying and can turn the jury and judge against you which, naturally, is utterly devastating to you.
 That Was Objectionable / int_9dd8fa62
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_9dd8fa62
featureConfidence
1.0
 LegalEagle (Web Video)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_9dd8fa62
 That Was Objectionable / int_a2aa0c7b
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_a2aa0c7b
comment
In one of Denis Norden's humorous monologues on My Word!, he described how he was in court for allegedly assaulting his ballroom dancing partner. At one point, the prosecutor dances with her in order to demonstrate how the ordeal has ruined her ability. Norden instantly jumps up.
 That Was Objectionable / int_a2aa0c7b
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_a2aa0c7b
featureConfidence
1.0
 My Word! (Radio)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_a2aa0c7b
 That Was Objectionable / int_a4420d22
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_a4420d22
comment
The Venture Bros.: in "Trial of the Monarch", Dr. Venture raises an objection from the gallery about the lewd content of the Monarch's testimony .
 That Was Objectionable / int_a4420d22
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_a4420d22
featureConfidence
1.0
 The Venture Bros.
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_a4420d22
 That Was Objectionable / int_a8729c90
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_a8729c90
comment
The Fairly OddParents!: Timmy Turner didn't have better grounds than the case above when he had to convince the Fairy Council he's not the worst godchild ever. He objected on the grounds he was losing. Later on, when the case was turned on his favor and the Fairy Council was about to acquit him, the Prosecutor objected and, when asked for grounds, he started searching through his papers until he found Timmy's Secret Wish.
 That Was Objectionable / int_a8729c90
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_a8729c90
featureConfidence
1.0
 The Fairly OddParents!
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_a8729c90
 That Was Objectionable / int_ab67d84
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_ab67d84
comment
There was a Ctrl-Alt-Del comic about Metal Gear Ac!d where a guard, after facing a card which allows him to be shot, says "I object on the ground that it sucks for me".
 That Was Objectionable / int_ab67d84
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_ab67d84
featureConfidence
1.0
 Ctrl+Alt+Del (Webcomic)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_ab67d84
 That Was Objectionable / int_af583f46
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_af583f46
comment
Franziska does this in Justice For All. "Objection! I... I... I object... For objection's sake..." Hilariously, this is actually a case of Reality Is Unrealistic — she'd already objected, so while the outburst itself wasn't necessary, it would technically be a continuing objection.
 That Was Objectionable / int_af583f46
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_af583f46
featureConfidence
1.0
 Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney – Justice For All (Visual Novel)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_af583f46
 That Was Objectionable / int_afa6cc7d
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_afa6cc7d
comment
In The Trial Of Tim Heidecker, Tim represents himself and frequently launches spurious objections, of which all but one end up being overruled by an (increasingly aggravated) Judge Szymczyk.
 That Was Objectionable / int_afa6cc7d
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_afa6cc7d
featureConfidence
1.0
 The Trial Of Tim Heidecker (Web Video)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_afa6cc7d
 That Was Objectionable / int_b6b24d18
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_b6b24d18
comment
In the final episode of The IT Crowd a central piece of evidence in Victoria's case is a sex tape made by Douglas Reynholm. After Victoria's lawyer decides that that enough of the tape has been shown and switches it off, Douglas objects with:
 That Was Objectionable / int_b6b24d18
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_b6b24d18
featureConfidence
1.0
 The IT Crowd
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_b6b24d18
 That Was Objectionable / int_b8e28f2e
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_b8e28f2e
comment
Good Omens (2019): In a Kangaroo Court scene in Hell, the prosecuting demon objects to the defendant's request to speak in his own defense, arguing that the charges are obviously indefensible. Hell being Hell, the objection is upheld.
 That Was Objectionable / int_b8e28f2e
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_b8e28f2e
featureConfidence
1.0
 Good Omens (2019)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_b8e28f2e
 That Was Objectionable / int_bb7d6a95
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_bb7d6a95
comment
In one episode of Duckman, Bernice is testifying as to Duckman's character.
 That Was Objectionable / int_bb7d6a95
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_bb7d6a95
featureConfidence
1.0
 Duckman
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_bb7d6a95
 That Was Objectionable / int_bfa1d565
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_bfa1d565
comment
Happens with Denny Crane in Boston Legal season 3 episode 10 "The Nutcracker" after opposing counsel badgers a witness.
 That Was Objectionable / int_bfa1d565
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_bfa1d565
featureConfidence
1.0
 Boston Legal
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_bfa1d565
 That Was Objectionable / int_c226c6d7
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_c226c6d7
comment
The illustrated version of The Wee Free Men includes a transcript of the case "Princess Sandy of Brokenrock vs. Fairy Nettle". When the wicked witch is mentioned, her lawyer jumps up and says "I object!" on the grounds she isn't actually wicked. The judge responds "Oh good. I was hoping someone would."
 That Was Objectionable / int_c226c6d7
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_c226c6d7
featureConfidence
1.0
 The Wee Free Men
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_c226c6d7
 That Was Objectionable / int_cac20f89
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_cac20f89
comment
JAG:
Deconstructed in the second season episode "Rendezvous", when incriminating evidence is presented and the defendant asks defense counsel to object.
Inverted for laughs in another episode, when Bud is so tired and overworked that he ends up nodding off in the middle of a case. Mack, who's the presiding judge, has to wake him up to ask him if he wants to object to something the prosecutor said.
 That Was Objectionable / int_cac20f89
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_cac20f89
featureConfidence
1.0
 JAG
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_cac20f89
 That Was Objectionable / int_cc547db9
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_cc547db9
comment
An interesting variant in Picket Fences. After Wambaugh pulls a completely legal but morally slimy legal maneuver, Judge Bone orders him jailed for contempt. When he asks why, Bone replies "for being contemptible."
 That Was Objectionable / int_cc547db9
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_cc547db9
featureConfidence
1.0
 Picket Fences
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_cc547db9
 That Was Objectionable / int_cda90e39
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_cda90e39
comment
In The Exorcism of Emily Rose, the attorney for the priest accused of criminal neglect of Emily Rose puts on a "demonology" expert to testify that Emily was possessed. The prosecutor objects. When the judge asks for a reason, he says, "How about silliness, your honor?" Though he could have phrased it better, that's still a reasonable objection.
 That Was Objectionable / int_cda90e39
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_cda90e39
featureConfidence
1.0
 The Exorcism of Emily Rose
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_cda90e39
 That Was Objectionable / int_cf39ca4f
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_cf39ca4f
comment
In a Pearls Before Swine strip where the Crocs, represented by Rat, are suing Zebra, whose lawyer is the Guard Duck. At one point in the deposition, Rat says "I object. I object to you. I object to your face. And your mama's fat." After which, the Guard Duck tells Zebra "this could get contentious."
 That Was Objectionable / int_cf39ca4f
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_cf39ca4f
featureConfidence
1.0
 Pearls Before Swine (Comic Strip)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_cf39ca4f
 That Was Objectionable / int_d14bb14a
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_d14bb14a
comment
One of the Special Episodes features Edgeworth solving a puzzle. His victory one-liner is a Call-Back to his trope-naming original quote.
 That Was Objectionable / int_d14bb14a
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_d14bb14a
featureConfidence
1.0
 Call-Back
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_d14bb14a
 That Was Objectionable / int_d30c7c2b
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_d30c7c2b
comment
Guardians of Pokémon: Being a parody of the already over-the-top Ace Attorney series, it was bound to happen eventually in Chapter 148. Mitsumi objects to the entire trial when Blight goes too far over the top trying to frame Gary for some sort of crime.
 That Was Objectionable / int_d30c7c2b
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_d30c7c2b
featureConfidence
1.0
 Guardians of Pokémon / Fan Fic
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_d30c7c2b
 That Was Objectionable / int_db96ded4
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_db96ded4
comment
In an episode of The Legend of Korra, Tonraq and other South Tribe men are being put on trial for possible rebel activity. When they are found guilty, Bolin interrupts the judge's sentencing with an "Objection!", only to shrink back in his seat when the judge barks at him to sit down.
 That Was Objectionable / int_db96ded4
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_db96ded4
featureConfidence
1.0
 The Legend of Korra
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_db96ded4
 That Was Objectionable / int_dd8198f3
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_dd8198f3
comment
In an episode of Las Vegas an Amoral Attorney tries to net a hefty salary by encouraging his client to pursue a Frivolous Lawsuit against the Montecito. He objects during a meeting with the casino's bosses and main lawyer when he's not even in a courtroom, which is duly pointed out to him.
 That Was Objectionable / int_dd8198f3
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_dd8198f3
featureConfidence
1.0
 Las Vegas
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_dd8198f3
 That Was Objectionable / int_e6275a02
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_e6275a02
comment
From Looking for Group:
 That Was Objectionable / int_e6275a02
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_e6275a02
featureConfidence
1.0
 Looking for Group (Webcomic)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_e6275a02
 That Was Objectionable / int_e7a9c06c
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_e7a9c06c
comment
In the Paperinik New Adventures issue Fragments of Autumn, PK's friend Lyla is tried for shooting a fellow officer. At one point, PK, who was excluded from the hall at the moment, objects... Since no one else was doing it. This gets him banned from testifying.
 That Was Objectionable / int_e7a9c06c
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_e7a9c06c
featureConfidence
1.0
 Paperinik New Adventures (Comic Book)
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_e7a9c06c
 That Was Objectionable / int_eae4fe0a
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_eae4fe0a
comment
A client does this on Judge Rinder:
 That Was Objectionable / int_eae4fe0a
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_eae4fe0a
featureConfidence
1.0
 Judge Rinder
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_eae4fe0a
 That Was Objectionable / int_eeb094a8
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_eeb094a8
comment
A Few Good Men. The prosecution puts on a doctor to give his opinion as to the cause of Willie Santiago's death. Lt. Cmdr. Galloway objects on the basis of his qualifications. When the judge overrules her, she "strenuously objects" and is again overruled. She ends up just making it look like they're afraid of the doctor's testimony.
 That Was Objectionable / int_eeb094a8
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_eeb094a8
featureConfidence
1.0
 A Few Good Men
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_eeb094a8
 That Was Objectionable / int_ef076a36
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_ef076a36
comment
In the Star Trek: Voyager/Doctor Who crossover "In Thy Image" by Paul Gadzikowski (later adapted as a comic in the style of Paul's The Hero of Three Faces, the Doctor is representing the Emergency Medical Hologram in a hearing to prove the EMH's personhood. When the Starfleet JAG attorney suggests that the EMH's failure to take a name indicates a recognition that he's not a person, content to be known only by his function — a doctor — his counsel naturally objects.
 That Was Objectionable / int_ef076a36
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_ef076a36
featureConfidence
1.0
 Star Trek: Voyager
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_ef076a36
 That Was Objectionable / int_ff9ab17f
type
That Was Objectionable
 That Was Objectionable / int_ff9ab17f
comment
Star Trek: The Next Generation:
In the episode "The Measure of a Man" Picard defends Data in a courtroom process, objecting to a plan that would see him labelled as Starfleet "property" and dismantled. The prosecution, for their case against Data, requests to remove the defendant's hand. Picard is immediately on his feet with his objections before realizing that he can't actually object in a legal manner-in typical Picard style, he just doesn't like the idea of them removing his second officer's body parts-and withdraws his objection.
In the episode "Devil's Due", Picard argues a court case against a woman claiming to be Ardra, a supernatural being in Velexian myth, with Data arbitrating. Ardra objects when Picard leads a witness, while Data himself objects to Ardra's Courtroom Antics in displaying her "powers" ("The advocate will refrain from making her opponent disappear"). When the Enterprise crew gets hold of her technology and Picard starts displaying the same powers, Ardra objects again, but Data decides he's allowed some leeway in the circumstances. Once Picard has successfully duplicated the tricks Ardra used earlier, and only those tricks, Data promptly declares that Picard's leeway has run out.
 That Was Objectionable / int_ff9ab17f
featureApplicability
1.0
 That Was Objectionable / int_ff9ab17f
featureConfidence
1.0
 Star Trek: The Next Generation
hasFeature
That Was Objectionable / int_ff9ab17f

The following is a list of statements referring to the current page from other pages.

 That Was Objectionable
processingCategory2
Artistic License – Law
 That Was Objectionable
processingCategory2
Comedy Tropes
 That Was Objectionable
processingCategory2
Dialogue
 That Was Objectionable
processingCategory2
Older Than Television
 That Was Objectionable
processingCategory2
The Courtroom Index
 Hellish Bells (Fanfic) / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 A Few Good Men / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Disorder In The Court / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Duck Soup / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Fatal Instinct / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Judgment at Nuremberg / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Liar Liar / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Newsies / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Ace Attorney (Franchise) / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 A Civil Action / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Little Fuzzy / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Rats, Bats and Vats / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 DasAuto
seeAlso
That Was Objectionable
 PandoraInactiveCanons
seeAlso
That Was Objectionable
 All Rise / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 JAG / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Las Vegas / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Law & Order / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Porridge / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 The Good Wife / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Three's Company / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Inherit the Wind (Theatre) / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Trial by Jury (Theatre) / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Turnabout Musical (Theatre) / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Batman: Arkham City (Video Game) / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney (Visual Novel) / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney – Spirit of Justice (Visual Novel) / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Turnabout Storm (Web Animation) / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 SMPLive (Web Video) / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Sorry (2023) (Web Video) / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Looking for Group (Webcomic) / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Aladdin and the King of Thieves / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Brickleberry / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Teen Titans Go! / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable
 Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney – Dual Destinies (Visual Novel) / int_375b6a06
type
That Was Objectionable